If you’re a homeowner in Sheffield City Centre thinking about selling, brace yourself for a bit of uncomfortable truth.
There is a growing gap in our city between what home sellers want and what buyers are actually willing to pay. And the evidence for this is laid out, month after month, in cold, hard numbers.
Since the summer of 2020, we’ve been tracking two key numbers: the average asking price of homes coming to market in Sheffield City Centre, and the average sale price of homes that exchanged and completed. The results are striking and eye-opening.
In 2025 so far, the average asking price of the homes coming onto the market in Sheffield City Centre has been £304,000. But the average price of a Sheffield City Centre home that’s actually sold and completed is £291,300. That’s a 4.3% difference.
And no, this isn’t about a property crash or Sheffield City Centre sellers taking a 4% or more hit on their asking prices. This is about what sells versus what sits on the market.
It’s Not That Sheffield City Centre House Prices Are Falling. It’s That High-Priced Sheffield City Centre Homes Don’t Sell as Well
Let’s be very clear. This 4.3% gap doesn’t mean house prices have dropped by 4.3%. It simply shows that Sheffield City Centre homes at the higher end of the market are much less likely to sell. They get listed, they linger, and they often withdraw unsold. Meanwhile, lower-priced Sheffield City Centre homes tend to fly off the shelf.
It’s a classic case of saleability versus ambition.
In 2020, the gap between average asking and average sale price in Sheffield City Centre was -2.1% (£247,000 asking vs £252,300 selling).
By 2021, it was -0.1%. Rose to 4.3% in 2022, was 2.0% in 2023, 3.8% in 2024, and now we’re at 4.3% in 2025 (Sheffield City Centre is S1/2/3/6/10/11).
Higher Price Brackets in Sheffield City Centre Have Lower Odds of Selling
It’s a simple truth: the higher up the price range you go, the harder it is to get a deal done.
That doesn’t mean the more expensive Sheffield City Centre homes won’t sell. But it does mean your pricing and presentation must be spot on for it to sell.
Wishful thinking won’t cut it.
The average asking price of property that has come on the market in Sheffield City Centre in the last five years has been £271,400.
- For all the Sheffield City Centre homes that have come onto the market below £271,400 in the last 5 years, they have had a 67.5% chance of selling and homeowners moving.
- For all the Sheffield City Centre homes that have come onto the market above £271,400 in the last 5 years, they have had a 71.4% chance of selling and homeowners moving.
Realistic Pricing Matters
Here’s another stat Sheffield City Centre home sellers need to understand.
Homes that agree a sale within 25 days of coming onto the market have a 94% chance of subsequently exchanging contracts and completing (i.e. the homeowner moves). Yet, for homes that sit for 100 days or more before a sale is agreed, the odds of the homeowner moving drop to just 56%.
In other words, if you get the price right from day one, you are far more likely to secure a solid buyer and sail through to completion. But if your home languishes on the portals for months, you are not only likely to have to reduce, if you do indeed manage to agree a sale on it, your odds are only slightly better than a flip of a coin.
What This Means for Sheffield City Centre Homeowners
If you’re thinking of putting your home on the market this year, here’s the uncomfortable but helpful advice:
- Don’t just look at what homes are being listed for. Look at what's selling — and selling within a month or two.
- Be honest about your timeframe. If you want to move soon, pricing realistically from day one will give you a better shot.
- Higher-value homes must work harder. Presentation, photography, pricing, and agent skill all matter more than ever when your Sheffield City Centre home sits in the upper price bands.
The Bottom Line for Sheffield City Centre Homeowners
Many homes listed in Sheffield City Centre this year won’t sell.
Not because they are bad homes. Not because the market is broken. But because many sellers and yes, some estate agents, are still pricing for the market they wish they had, rather than the market we do have.
If your Sheffield City Centre home is priced at the top of its range, you must demand an agent who can justify every pound, back it up with real buyer insights, and be honest with you from the start.
Otherwise, you risk becoming part of the Sheffield City Centre homeowners that don’t sell, as opposed to the Sheffield City Centre homeowners that move to the next chapter of their life.
To find out more about the Sheffield property market contact the branch.
