Over the past five years, Sheffield City centre's private rental market has experienced a significant growth in rents. The average monthly rent has increased from £737 in 2020 to £990 in 2025, representing a 34% rise.
These local trends are interesting when compared with the national picture, where the average monthly rent increased from £1,331 in 2020 to £1,803 in 2025, a rise of 35%. Regionally, in Yorkshire and the Humber, the rent rose from £757 to £1,003, a 32% increase.
Yet, as affordability tightens, some landlords who were too optimistic with their pricing have been forced to reduce their asking rents; 24% of rental listings across the UK experienced price adjustments in 2025 alone. Despite this, tenants in Sheffield City centre are now paying substantially more than they were just five years ago.
Next, let’s look at the supply of rental properties in Sheffield City centre over the last five years. Even though the level of rental listings coming onto the market has increased slightly (which bucks the national trend), demand has still outstripped supply as rents have increased.
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2020 - 772
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2021 - 721
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2022 - 713
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2023 - 738
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2024 - 765
- Sheffield City centre averaged new rental listings each month in 2025 - 786
Seasonal trends are also notable. Rental supply tends to peak in late spring and early autumn, with October being particularly strong (because of the student market), while winter months, especially December, show the lowest levels. This cyclical pattern was disrupted during the pandemic but has since resumed, albeit with generally lower volumes.
The current imbalance of limited supply and high demand has tightened the market. Nationally, rental availability remains more than 25% below pre-pandemic levels.
In Sheffield City centre, agents continue to report strong tenant demand, though the frenzy seen in 2022 and 2023 has calmed somewhat. Low vacancy rates persist, and while the supply/demand gap may be narrowing slightly, it remains significant.
Analysts estimate that 50,000 more rental homes are needed nationwide each year to restore pre-2020 availability. Until that gap closes, upward pressure on rents in cities like Sheffield City centre is likely to continue. While the scale of rental increases is expected to moderate compared to previous years, I am forecasting a further 3% to 4% rental growth in 2025.
Challenges and Opportunities for Sheffield City Centre Landlords
The outlook for landlords in Sheffield City centre is a mix of pressure and potential. While rents are higher and tenant demand remains strong, landlords face rising costs, evolving regulations, and taxation changes.
Challenges for Sheffield City Centre Landlords
- Regulation and Reform: The planned Renters’ Rights Bill in England is one of the most significant changes on the horizon. It proposes the abolition of Section 21 'no fault' evictions and introduces stronger tenant protections. This is a source of concern for many landlords, particularly when managing tenancies that are problematic. Proposed changes to minimum EPC ratings have added to the pressure, with nearly one in two landlords in many surveys expressing concern about the cost of improving older properties.
- Rising Finance and Maintenance Costs: Interest rate hikes have driven buy-to-let mortgage rates from between 2% and 3% just after the pandemic to 5% or more by 2024. However, the Bank of England's recent lowering of its base rate to its current level of 4.25% has not squeezed landlord profit margins as much. However, inflation has also increased the cost of repairs and materials. This is important as many landlords now spend around a fifth of their rental income on maintenance.
- Taxation Pressure: Recent changes to mortgage interest relief and Capital Gains Tax have reduced profitability for many Sheffield City centre landlords. Since 2017, higher-rate taxpayers have been required to pay tax on rental income before deducting interest, thereby reducing their net yield. Added to this are potential further CGT reforms and the administrative burden of Making Tax Digital. These pressures have already contributed to an exodus of some landlords. Data from TwentyEA indicated that in Q1 2025, 15.6% of homes listed for sale were previously rented, up from 9.8% the previous year.
- Tenant Expectations and Affordability: With living costs high, tenants expect more from their homes, including better insulation, faster broadband, and modern amenities. Rent arrears remain a concern, with research from Denton House showing that between 5% and 6% of UK tenants with self-managing landlords are in arrears, and just under 2% with managed properties. Sheffield City centre landlords must now carefully balance rental increases with the long-term sustainability of their tenants. The shift to rolling tenancies under the reform proposals prioritises tenant retention.
Opportunities for Sheffield City Centre Landlords
- Strong Tenant Demand: Despite economic pressures, Sheffield City centre continues to see strong rental demand. Its affordability and good connectivity make it attractive for couples and families alike. Sheffield City centre properties in good condition let quickly, with minimal voids.
- Improved Yields: Rising rents have lifted yields to their highest point in a decade. For those Sheffield City centre landlords without mortgages or with low debt, increased rental income directly boosts profitability. Even landlords with mortgages can maintain healthy margins if rental prices remain strong.
- Reduced Competition: As some Sheffield City centre landlords exit the sector, those who stay benefit from less competition. The expansion of existing landlords' portfolios, along with a fresh wave of new, motivated landlords, means that new investment opportunities exist. If you are a Sheffield City centre landlord, we can consult our existing landlord database to see if any portfolios could be purchased at a fair price with existing tenants in the properties.
In conclusion, Sheffield City centre's rental market presents both challenges and opportunities. Landlords willing to navigate the changing landscape, invest in quality, and adapt to evolving tenant expectations can still find it a profitable and resilient investment.
Whether you are a self-managing landlord or a landlord who uses another agent in Sheffield City centre, if you would like to pick my brain on the best strategies to employ, please give me a call.
To find out more about the Sheffield property market contact the branch.
